Restaurant Reviews

Last Modified November 6, 2005

Hartford area

Grant’s, on Farmington Avenue in West Hartford Center, has far and away the best value in town in their early bird specials – if you order before 6:00, you can get a three-course meal (appetizer, main course, dessert) for $25. The portions are generous, the selection broad (typically six or eight choices of entree; usually salmon, always some chicken and beef, and other choice), and most are from the main menu with perhaps a less glitzy garnish. If you’re looking for recommendations, the huge portion of calamari fritti and the French country salad (meaning “with bacon”) are wonderful appetizers; the enormous roast chicken breast and the trout with lentils are usually to die for.  It is however easy to drink up the savings (wine by the glass tends to run $7-$12, and though there are some good wines on the list under $30, there aren’t many). If you don’t make the six o’clock deadline the prices increase, but the food (modern American with some diner favorites like meatloaf) is as good as any around, and frequently better. The huge, slender room isn’t to everyone’s taste but the service is good. Last visited October 2005.

Peppercorn’s Grill, on Main Street in Hartford next to Spiritus, clearly thinks it serves the best food in the area if not the state, and they may be right. Focusing on Northern Italian cuisine, the extensive menu offers a broad variety of choices ranging from plain grilled foods through pastas, fish, chicken, beef, and veal (pork is rarely served except in charcuterie). The veal choices are so good that we typically stick with them and the pastas, but we’ve never had bad food and are probaly missing out on some exceptional alternatives. (You can see the menu, and the wine list, from the linked web page; they also typically have a full page of daily specials in all categories.) Expect to spend $25 and up – far up – for a bottle of wine, but the prices are fair for what you get. (A 2000 Zenato Amarone was $85 – a wonderful Amarone that is perhaps a little young to drink; a 2001 Gaja Charonnay, almost never seen in restaurants here, was $100 and heavenly). The room is elegant, but the tables feel cramped together;

But ... Peppercorns is a restaurant with an attitude and the attitude is that you’re lucky to be there. Last visit, the lobster and artichoke salad was served with mushrooms instead of artichokes. The mushrooms were delicious, but it would have been nice to have been told of the substitution. (The lobster, two claws and the accomanying arm meat, was icy at the center and light on flavor.) The veal tenderloin with truffled jus was served with perfectly cooked spinach and mashed potatoes that had died and gone to heaven; the quality came from the potatoes and their cooking, not just from oodles of butter and cream. But the veal, ordered medium rare, was without apology delivered very rare, and the truffles in the jus were impossible to detect, a far cry from the heavenly perfume we recalled from previous occasions. The Connecticut Opera tells subscribers that Peppercorns will give them 20% off on two entrees, but the restaurant says that’s a “mistake” (they don’t seem to have tried to get the Opera to correct it) and offers 20% off on one entree, one card per table (another limitation nowhere mentioned in the materials distributed).

So ... you can go to Peppercorn’s and, if everything works, get a wonderful meal, great wines, and an elegant experience. But if things go wrong, don’t expect them to apologize. We’ve never had bad food there, but we often haven’t enjoyed the experience. Caveat emptor. Last visited November 2005.

Piccolo Arancio, in Farmington, is Peppercorns’ sister. Next to a motel, the rooms are larger, the tables more generously spaced, and the staff generaly more interested in pleasing the customers.  The menu and wine list are similar but not identical (for instance, the Gaja chardonnay that was $100 in town is $90 here), and some of the fancier dishes are missing. However, the cooking’s still excellent and overall we’ve had better experiences here than at Peppercorns. The only real drawback is location; this is too far to go before a night at the opera. Last visited summer 2005.

Szechuan Garden, a restaurant in the space once occupied by Metropol and Shangri-La (see below), is a marvellous new effort with outstanding Szechuan dishes. They have a general menu, which is okay, but the glory of the restaurant is found on their menu inserts of Szechuan specialties. A particular joy is their dinner for four (soup, plus choice of one entree from each of four categories, including one fish and one shellfish) for $50. If you're picking individually, I can especially recommend the "strange flavor chicken" and dried tofu salad from the appetizers (about $5 each), or the double sauteed pork belly, "Ants climbing the tree" (noodles with pork bits) or any of the whole fishes. The more adventurous can try sea cucumber, duck tongue, pig ear, and beef tendons. Appetizers run from $3 to $6, main courses from $8 to $18 (which gets you a whole fish, enough for two). Update September 11, 2005. They’re still going, but with at least new staff; we had to ask for the Szechuan menu, but once we asked we got it. Pork with preserved cabbage soup was plentiful and tasty though mild flavored; shrimp with preserved Szechuan vegetable was plentiful and delicious. We were the only Westerners in the nearly empty restaurant. The day was warm, not hot, and they didn’t have the air-conditioning on. 904 Farmington Ave., 231-7677. Last visited September 2005.

Monte Alban, on Farmington Avenue down from the Law School, is a pretty good Mexican restaurant, with food ranging from tacos, burritos, and enchiladas through a variety of fancier specials. From the outside it looks a bit like a hole in the wall; inside is pleasant and clean. Three years ago I was there for dinner (the fancier stuff) which was okay not great; more recently, at lunch, the tacos (I had Pastor, spicy pork) were excellent, served with tasty rice and beans and an optional tasty dark red chili sauce (mildly spicy). Based on that lunch I’d say it’s excellent; the one caveat is that the lunch menu is no cheaper than the dinner menu, so two orders of tacos and one of guacamole and chips came to $25. Last visited September 2005.

Cate's Corner Bistro is a promising newcomer in downtown Hartford, at the corner of Main Street and Capitol Avenue where Savannah’s used to be. The main dining room in front is airy and pleasant, with high ceilings and a high brick wall; tables are comfortably spaced, and several look pleasantly out over the street if you enjoy watching people walk by. The dinner menu is bistro food tending towards the Italian, with a few surprises. The cooking ranges from stunningly good (crab cakes, $22, as good as they are in Annapolis, so good I ate them with just a squeeze of lemon and ignored the excellent tartar sauce) to bistro-good (the veal dishes, for instance, about $17).  Pastas (about $12) have been quite tasty and extremely generously portioned. The small roster of desserts is excellent, and the wine list similarly small but carefully selected; the Groh chardonnay from California ($39) was delightful and a Pinot Gris from Oregon equally good value. Bottles ranged from $20 to $60.

If you’re eating downtown, try Cate’s. It’s not crowded, it’s relatively inexpensive for the quality of food, and the service is friendly and knoledgeable. The Courant’s food critic, Michael Gannon, savaged the place in an entirely unprofessional review that said more about Gannon’s high opinion of himself than it did about the food, so it may need some help to survive. 391 Main St.,Hartford. 860-727-1124. Last visited October 2005.

King and I Thai at 1901 Park Street (right next to Casa Lisboa) has changed owners yet again but still provides the best Thai food in the area. The menu’s expanded considerably since its last incarnation, with a larger selection but more standard choices; they also have a whiteboard of daily specials. Appetizers are about $4 to $7, main courses $8 to $12,  and they have sticky rice for those who love it. Last trip the seafood salad was to die for, the seafood with Panang currey excellent, the duck special crispy and spicy (if sweeter than I like, but that’s personal taste), and the spicy rice noodles very good. Takeout available; most dishes $1 cheaper at lunch; bring your own liquor. Last visited October 2005.

The East West Grill, at 526 New Park Avenue just about across from Home Depot, is the only (partly) Laotian restaurant in the area. We've been there three times; two meals were wonderful, the third — after a rave review in the Courant, and when the restaurant was more crowded — was good. I hope the third visit was just an off day. Yarng gai noy, barbecued Cornish game hen ($8.95 at dinner, a couple bucks cheaper at lunch) is delicious, nicely barbecued whole game hen with a delicious Lao hot sauce on the side that you can consume or ignore at your pleasure. Seen Hang (Laotian beef jerkey) is delicious beef jerkey, but you have to like the dried texture to enjoy it (I did); $8.50. Probably the best of the batch was Larb Seen, delicious thin-sliced grilled beef with mint and spices ($8.95). We've liked all the noodle dishes, salads, and soups that we've tried. The only losers have been the dumplings. The gyoza were okay ($4.75), but the shrimp shu mai were losers both times — apparently frozen, they were noticeably less good than the packaged variety you can get at A. Dong's supermarket in Shield Plaza. All of the main courses come with a choice of sticky rice (Laotian and Northern Thai specialty) or regular boiled rice.

China Pan, in the shopping center beyond Westfarms, behind Borders, is unpretentious,and little known. On a good night it can be the second best Chinese in the Hartford area (particularly its Shanghai and vegetarian specialties), but on a bad night the food can be distinctly mediocre — particularly the Hunan dishes. (Recently we got a “Hunan Chicken” that was dry, not at all spicy though we’d asked for “extra-spicy,” and in general seemed as if it had been waiting around since lunch.The sauteed bean leaf tips can be absolutely heavenly, but recently they’ve tended to be poorly trimmed and on the tough side; still tasty, but not an $11 vegetable dish. The vegetarian goose meat is bean curd skin wrapped around mushrooms and bean curd, served with baby bok choy in a tasty brown sauce; don’t miss it. Dim Sum on weekends. The daily brunch is great value (about $6), but uneven. October 2002.

La Casona, on Wethersfield Avenue just beyond Brainard Road, a convenient spot for dinner after a matinee at Hoyt’s Conema City, is a new South American restaurant with a cheerful staff determined to please. To my not too educated palate I’d say that the menu centers on Argentinian and Caribbean foods, but I could be wrong. The portions are very big; we stuffed ourselves on two main courses, and the waitress said that the squid appetizer would feed several. The parillada ($16) was half an excellent sausage, a good sized piece of rib eye steak, a slice of chicken breast, and a big chunk of pork rib, served with an okay mushroom sauce and a very tasty chimichurri. "Tierra Aire" subtracted the pork and sausage (and the chimichurri sauce) and substituted a grilled, rather dry lobster tail ($20). It was fine but we wouldn’t try that again. There’s a good selection of (mostly Chilean) wines by the glass, about $6 and $7; a similar selection of bottles ($20-$30); and quite a few drink choices (about $7). If you don’t see it, ask; the Pisco Sour (not on the menu) was extremely good. 681 Wethersfield Ave., 296-9929. Last visited August 2004.

Min Ghung in Glastonbury  pitches itself as an “asian bistro,”  and  offers what as far as I know is the largest selection of quality sake  within 100 miles.  They offer a goodly selection of sushi and sashimi, including both classic selections and others (mostly rolls) clearly aimed at Western tastes (e.g. the Snow Roll, “Apple, cream cheese & kani, and the roll is fried.”). The rest of the menu is a mix of Japanese, Thai, Korean, and eclectic. The restaurant itself is a large, open space (with a nice patio) in a mall that feels like a clone of the Exchange in Farmington.

We had a lovely time for our one meal. We tend not to like sweet flavors with meat and so had to dodge a lot of the entrees (the spicy pork, bul go gi, and short ribs all emphasize honey) but with a little care that was possible. The slow cooked rainbow trout was outstanding (we thought smoked, but they said pan cooked), the avocado eggrolls unusual and tasty, and all the sushi we tried, from uni through a Kill Bill roll” was delicious. The sake selection (all served cool) is unique; resist the waitress’s attempts to have you order yourself, and chat up the bartender who knows them all well and, when you return, will likely remember what you had the last time. Since the sakes are quite different, you’ll likely want to wait until you’ve chosen your food to choose them. If you don’t like sake, they have a full bar and a small selection of beer and wine. They have live music (relatively quiet) on Thursday and Saturday. 39 New London Turnpike, Glastonbury; 860.659.2568.

Azul, a new restaurant in a former bank building on LaSalle Road in West Hartford, is gorgeous inside; it gives you the feeling of a nice restaurant in Miami Beach. Most everyone we know loves it; we’ve been disappointed each time we’ve been there (two dinners and a lunch).

The food is good but not wonderful. Black bean soup and duck and goat quesadillas were bothe fine, but nothing to run for. Beef tenderloin, which came rarer than requested, was fine too but the purple mashed potatoes were a little dry. The roast chicken looked gorgeous but was cool when it came out. Black beans and rice and plaintain chips were both tasty. Salmon was a disappointment (not bad, but not as good as homemade pan-roasted fish.) The wine list is broad and relatively inexpensive for a fancy restaurant. Service was just okay; we had to ask a couple of times to get our water glasses filled. All in all, we'd say you'll have a good time, the surroundings are delightful, but there's nothing we're dying to eat again. Last visited February 2004.

Dim Sum is a small restaurant in Shield Street plaza (right next to the wonderful A. Dong’s Oriental supermarket, and a few doors down from Pho, a Vietnamese restaurant) that, uniquely in the Hartford area, serves dim sum from rolling trays every day from before noon until at least dinner time. Since we’ve been visiting it, it’s gone through a couple changes of ownership and at least one change of style (for a brief, horrid period it tried to turn into a lunch buffet). Most of the time they have an ordinary menu, but that’s not the reason to go. The reason, quite simply, is the best dim sum in town and maybe the best within 100 miles.

The dim sum comes on rolling trays. Point, and ye shall be served. If you don’t like what you see, wait for the next tray (though a few items have to be ordered specially). Be sure to try the seaweed salad if it doesn’t show up. We tend to prefer the various translucent-wrapper items (several kinds of shrimp fillings), the chinese chive dumplings, the marvellous bean curd skin with pork, but we’ve never had anything badly made (though we can’t say we enjoyed the spicy chicken feet — and not because of the spice). $20 will stuff two hogs (us) at lunchtime. Highly recommended. Last visited June 2004.

Pho Boston, a few doors down from Dim Sum in Shield Street Plaza, serves mostly Vietnamese noodle soups, with a selection of other dishes. You can't beat the prices (under $5 for a big bowl of the basic pho, and many other things), and the food's pretty good, the servers enthusiastic when we were there. We've been there twice; egg rolls were okay, the soup (beef pho -- the beef in the soup is very skinny slices) delicious, and a spicy pork casserole ($6.50, the most expensive thing we ordered) was tasty, very hot, but a little on the salty side. (Probably if you ate it as many people do -- with a little meat and a lot of rice -- the salting would have been perfect.) Open every day, 9 to 9. Last visited September, 2002.

Coyote Flaco, the skinny coyote, may be small but it’s lovable. It’s run by a charming couple some of whose children may be wandering about during weekend days. The restaurant has a few nice blue tables and delicious food. The soup of the day was a very flavorful chicken broth with rice and some chicken. A chicken tamale was delicious; the tamale itself was on the light and fluffy side, not the solid tamales that you can eat with your hands. It came topped with a little melted cheese on a very hot plate (helpful, since the restaurant itself was on the chilly side this January day; everyone kept a coat on). Burritos — one “express,” without side dishes, and one with rice, beans, and salad — were the real kind, a flour tortilla stuffed with the meat you chose (beef, pork, chicken, ground beef, or sausage). We had a beef and a pork; the pork was tenderer, but both were tasty. The side rice was good, the side beans very good, and the small salad tasty. All in all, with coffee this cost about $17. In addition to standards (enchiladas, quesadillas, tacos, chili rellenos) they have combinations for $9 and grilled chicken, shrimp, and beef dishes from $7 to $15. I think they now sell beer.. All in all, a great addition, good for takeout and a nice place to eat before movies at Cinestudio. Open 7 days a week from 10 a.m. (noon Sundays) to 10 p.m. Takes VISA. Last visited August 2002..635 New Britain Avenue, Hartford, about 3/4 mile over the Hartford line from West Hartford. (860) 953-1299.

El Sombrero, on Queen Street in Newington, is the best Mexican choice for those who want liquor or don’t cotton to Coyote Flaco’s small menu and distinctive style. Although the food isn’t what you’d find in a restaurant in Mexico, the cooking all has a Mexican flair to it, and the menu gives more choices than most anyone needs; there are also a couple of daily specials. Portions are large. In addition to the standard burrito-enchilada collections, they serve quite a few sauced meats; anything with the pepita (pumpkin seed) sauce is likely to be particularly good. nt. Main courses $9 - $14. Last visited June 2004.

Puerta Vallarta opened a while back in West Hartford Center, the local incarnation of a Mexican chain popular on the West Coast.We first called it “promising,” but six months later we have to say that the promise is unfulfilled. Try at your own risk.

The menu is huge -- four large pages, plus an insert of more expensive dinner specials -- and they've got a broad selection of aged Tequila for those who like them. Foods range from the standard enchilada/burrito/taco/fajitas through tamales, chile relleno, several moles, and half a dozen fish dishes, emphasizing shrimp.

The salsa served with chips was stronger and darker than the standard, more chile and less tomato flavor, quite hot but good. Tortilla soup ($5 for a remarkably small bowl) was more like a vegetable stew despite the menu claim of large chunks of chicken. (The manager said they'd changed the recipe after the menus were printed, but didn't seem concerned that the menu was misinforming diners.) First brought out, the soup was lukewarm; when we complaned, we got a hot bowl. A chile relleno was a tasty large well cooked poblano chile stuffed with cheese (we thought the menu had promised meat, but didn't recheck) in an attractive and moderately spicy tomato sauce. A chicken burrito was large, mostly rice and beans, but decent. The special red snapper (in a garlic sauce with chopped octopus) was originally a disaster: under the spicy topping, the fish was cooked on one side, raw on the other, and frozen in the center. When we complained, they cheerfully took it back, returning a few minutes later with the same plate, somewhat messed up, and the fish cooked to a fare-the-well. Perhaps too well? It was the toughest fish I've ever eaten, impossible to cut with a fork, and far tougher than the octopus in the topping. I know of no way to make a red snapper this tough. Is it possible that too long in a freezer will do this?

Nevertheless, the dish tasted delicious. Flour tortillas than came on the side were superb. Portions of everything except the soup ranged from large (chile) to huge (burrito and fish); we took a good bit home. Two margaritas (Miguel's special) were tasty, but very different from each other (the first was sour, the second sweet). Either the water bobbled the order or the bartender makes them variably. August 9, 2000.

Another view: One of my students writes (August, 2001) that “It is my opinion... that the Puerta Vallarta is probably the closest one can get to "authentic" mexican. It's rare that I can eat anywhere back home and not have the pleasure of wading through incredible amounts of cheese, sauce or gravy. I will say that their salsa is probably a bit over-chili'ed and that the rice leaves a bit to be desired (tasting rather bland, or rather not tasting)._The rellenos are especially good (it must be incredibly hard to get the peppers up here with just the right mixture of sweet and spicy) and the tamales are some of the best I've ever eaten, bar none.”

The Frog and Peach, out in Canton just beyond Margaritas, is gone. The new restaurant in the same location is from the owner of the (also now closed) Back Street Grill in West Hartford.

Main Moon Buffet, on Prospect just south of Park, is remarkably inexpensive ($5 for lunch, $6.30 for dinner on weekdays, a little more on weekends) and serves quite palatable Chinese and some American foods buffet-style. Open from 11:30 every day. (January 11, 1998)

New Haven area

Thai Taste, 1151 Chapel Street, New Haven -- in what used to be the Rathskeller, and still has Yale oars on the wall -- just may be the best Thai restaurant in Connecticut. If not, it's very close. Luncheon dishes are $4 - $7 (and there are combos), dinner about 50% more expensive. For a wonder, if you ask for the food "Thai hot" it really is, so don't overstate your preferences. Among the appetizers, we particularly like the Thai dumplings ($3.50), rather like shiu mai but with a fried garlic on the top and a Thai edge to the spices; and the Som Tom, which they say is a papaya salad (doesn't seem like papaya to me, but it's wonderful ($4.95). We haven't had a loser among the curries and noodles, and can particularly recommend the spicy noodle (broad rice noodles; available with meat or vegetarian), Pik King shrimp (more string beans than shrimp, but delicious); and the Massaman curry (a milder coconut milk curry with potatoes and peanuts). We spent $38 for two appetizers, a noodle, a curry -- and a noodle and two curries to take home, lunchtime prices. (September 11, 1999)

Ibiza, New Haven. This is a new incarnation of Pika Tapas, and has switched from an emphasis on Tapas to a full-service, full-Spanish-meal restaurant. The Tapas, tasty and garlicky, were much as before, strong flavored and garlicky, but the selection is smaller. We haven't hit a loser yet. Main courses were generous and excellent. We’ve not tried many of the desserts, but the Catalan version of creme brulee (a little more tart than the usual) was spectacular. Wines (mostly Spanish) are available by the bottle; a small selection is available by the glass. They also serve beer (mostly American).  We spent $149 on dinner for two but that included not only lots of food but some pretty expensive wine. 39 High Street near the Museum of British Art. Last visited May, 2005.

Union Leage Cafe, New Haven. The long-running Union League Cafe serves probably the best French food in Connecticut this side of Stamford. The room is large and open, with high ceilings, lots of dark wood, and impeccable linens (there’s also a bar at the back). The menu, which slides slightly towards bistro cooking, changes frequently (we love the rabbit but rarely get there when it’s on) but always includes a good selection of seafoods and meats. Flavors are strong and clear; the staff friendly but professional; and the wine list, also bistro-like, emphasizes lesser-known wines that are often excellent value. They open at 5:30 so you can manage dinner before a play, but you’ll have a lot more fun if you leave time for a full, unhurried experience.   Last visited September, 2005.

Penguin Cafe, Branford. It used to be wonderful, but after the expansion the prices have gone way up (and they've gotten a liquor license) and the service is uneven. When everything hits just right, they're still wonderful, but no longer a bargain. When they swing and miss, you'll regret paying the price. (March, 1998). Go around the corner to Le Petit Cafe, prix fixe and delicious.

Elsewhere

Sienna Restaurant, South Deerfield, Massachusetts.We heard about this small (maybe a dozen tables) restaurant from some friends with excellent taste, who raved about the food they’d had on a return from Vermont. By the time we visited, Bill Cosby had been there and liked the food so much that he hired the chef as his personal cook. But the replacement is, at least, very good. For appetizers, mesclun salad, sauteed fois gras, and a duck terrine were all excellent and attractively served. Main courses were a little difficult, since one of our party is diabetic and can’t eat any of the starches that accompany most dishes. The menu says, severely, “No substitutions,” but at least the night we were there the chef was happy to provide a choice of sauteed greens as a substitution. Pan-seared halibut and rib-eye of lamb were first-rate, both cooked precisely as we'd asked, and beautifully accompanied. The duck breast, served rare, would please some but we found it a little fatty (you can’t really serve duck breast rare and melt off the fat at the same time). A poached pear with mascarpone cheese and walnuts was delicious, but the sabayon with it was little more than decoration on the plate (as the waitress warned us beforehand). Espresso was mediocre to terrible, but the waitress was happy to keep trying and we think took it off the bill. The wine list has a nice set of choices from moderate to pricey; we had an excellent Kistler chardonnay from California for $75 (it would have been hard to find in a wine store for less than $50, so there’s not a lot of markup), and a glass of Tokay (5 putts) with dessert. They’ve got a web site, so you can check out a representative menu (the one on the web wasn’t precisely what we saw, but it was close enough that we knew what to expect). Last visited September 16, 2004.

Jaleo, Washington, D.C.. Absolutely delightful and crowded tapas bar about 7th and E Street; we came in at 4:45 and wouldn't have gotten a seat an hour later. The tapas range from about $4 to $8; we particularly liked the lamb chops, the sausage in white beans, and the potatoes with goat cheese, but there was nothing we didn't like. Our helpful and attentive waiter was happy to let us order one at a time, adding a new one when he brought the first. Lots of wines by the glass (we had cava and sangria). The two of us spent about $45 for food and $30 for the wine. (December 2002)

Chinatown Express, Washington, D.C.. Inexpensive Chinatown storefront where you can watch the cook make noodles by hand (twisting, twisting, twisting) and get little Cantonese dumplings with the soup cooked inside the dumpling.Tasty, different, and extremely cheap. They have a larger menu for those who want; we stuck with the specialties. Our lunch cost a tenth of the previous night's dinner at Vidalia. (December 2002).

Vidalia, Washington, D.C.. One of the best restaurants in the city, it's said, and it was certainly full. The appetizers (crab cakes ($15) and a mushroom ragout ($13)) were delicious; the sirloin ($30) beautifully aged and cooked just as ordered. The sweetbreads and lobster ($29) were disappointing; too-large pillows of sweetbreads (nicely cooked, but they would have been crisper cut in smaller pieces) and a genuinely tiny half lobster tail.Disappointing, too, was the onion casserole ($5.50 side order); not nearly as good as a Julia Child soubise we made at home the following week. A buttermilk panna cotta was excellent, our Willm Pinot Gris ($30) a bargain, and the Vine Cliff Merlot ($41 for a half bottle) outstanding. (December 2002)

 

 

 

Back to the main page.